Guide · Savannah

Cabinet Painting vs. Replacing: Which Is Right for You?.

Tired kitchen cabinets leave you with two choices: paint them or replace them. Here is how they compare for Savannah and Lowcountry homes, and how to decide.

5.0 on Google · 38 reviewsSavannah, Georgia · English and Spanish · Licensed & insured · 2-year written warranty
Global Finishes crew on a real jobOur crew · real job

Cabinet Painting vs. Replacing: Quick Comparison

Both options can change how your kitchen looks and feels. They are very different in cost, disruption and what they can fix. Here is the short version, using plain comparisons instead of numbers, since every kitchen is different.

FactorCabinet PaintingCabinet Replacement
Upfront costA fraction of replacementMuch higher, and it grows with every add-on
TimelineShorter, and you keep a working kitchenLonger, with ordering and installation steps
DisruptionLow. Sink, stove and fridge stay usableHigh. The kitchen is torn out
DurabilityGood with proper prep, may need touch-ups over timeLongest lasting
Layout changesNot possiblePossible
Fixes damaged boxesOnly minor repairsYes

Cabinet Painting: A Closer Look

What Is Involved in Cabinet Painting?

Professional cabinet painting is much more than rolling on a coat of paint. A proper job follows steps like these:

  1. Removal: Doors, drawer fronts, hardware and shelves come off and are labeled.
  2. Cleaning: Years of cooking grease and hand oils are degreased, because paint will not hold over them.
  3. Sanding: Surfaces are sanded so the new finish can grip.
  4. Repairs: Dings, holes and worn spots are filled and smoothed.
  5. Bonding coat: A sealing, bonding coat of paint goes on first so the color coats stick and stains do not bleed through.
  6. Finish coats: Several thin coats of durable cabinet paint are applied, ideally as a sprayed finish for a smooth look.
  7. Reinstall: Doors are rehung and adjusted, and hardware goes back on.

Skipping any of these steps is why some painted cabinets chip or peel within a year.

Good to know: While cabinets are being painted, most of your kitchen stays usable. You will have less counter space for a while, but you keep your sink, stove and refrigerator.

What Drives the Cost of Cabinet Painting

There is no honest one-size answer, because the price depends on your kitchen. These are the factors that move it most:

  • Door and drawer count: More doors and drawer fronts means more surfaces to sand and finish.
  • Condition of the cabinets: Heavy grease, peeling paint or dents add prep time.
  • Existing finish: Glossy factory finishes and old stain need more work than bare or lightly finished wood.
  • Color change: Going from dark to light usually needs extra coats.
  • Finish system: A durable, sprayed cabinet finish costs more than a basic brush job, and it holds up better.
  • Islands, pantries and built-ins: Extra cabinet runs add to the scope.
  • Hardware: New pulls and hinges are an add-on, and fresh hardware often completes the look.
  • Site access: Space to work and spray, and where doors can be set to dry, affects the job.

The easiest way to know your number is a written quote. Get a free estimate and we will walk through your cabinets with you.

Advantages and Drawbacks of Painting

Why paint

  • Costs far less than new cabinets
  • Quicker, and your kitchen stays functional
  • No plumbing or electrical work
  • Keeps good cabinets out of the landfill
  • You can refresh the color again later

Drawbacks

  • Cannot change the layout or add storage
  • Will not fix warped doors or water damage
  • Hidden damage sometimes shows up once the old finish is off
  • Painted surfaces can need touch-ups, especially near the sink

Cabinet Replacement: A Closer Look

What Is Involved in Replacement?

Replacing cabinets is a full kitchen renovation. It usually includes:

  1. Planning: Design, measurements and layout decisions.
  2. Ordering: Cabinets are built or shipped to order, and that wait varies by type.
  3. Demolition: The old cabinets come out, and walls and floors may need repair.
  4. Trade work: Plumbing and electrical may need to be adjusted.
  5. Installation: New cabinets are set, leveled and secured.
  6. Finishing: Countertops, backsplash, trim, paint and hardware are completed.

Your kitchen is out of service for much of the project.

What Drives the Cost of Replacement

Replacement costs more upfront, and the total depends on several choices:

  • Cabinet grade: Stock, semi-custom and fully custom cabinets sit at very different levels.
  • Kitchen size and layout: Moving walls, sinks or appliances adds trade work.
  • Countertops and backsplash: These are often replaced at the same time.
  • Plumbing and electrical: Required when the layout changes.
  • Flooring and wall repair: Often exposed when the old cabinets come out.
  • Hardware and features: Soft close, pull outs and organizers all add up.

Advantages and Drawbacks of Replacing

Why replace

  • Brand new boxes, doors and drawers
  • Longest lifespan
  • A chance to redesign the layout and storage
  • Custom sizes and features

Drawbacks

  • Significantly higher cost
  • Longer project and a kitchen you cannot use
  • Often leads to other upgrades (counters, flooring, backsplash)
  • Surprises behind the walls can add to the scope

Thinking About Resale Value

Many homeowners ask whether the money comes back when they sell. Buyers respond strongly to a clean, bright, updated kitchen. They do not always pay in proportion for premium new cabinets over well-painted ones. Painting is usually the better value if you are selling soon. If you plan to stay for a long time, the durability and layout benefits of new cabinets can justify the higher spend. Your own goals matter more than any resale rule of thumb.

When to Paint and When to Replace

Paint your cabinets if:

  • The boxes are solid and the doors are straight
  • You like your current layout and storage
  • You want a big visual change without a remodel
  • You are selling soon or working with a tighter budget
  • Your cabinets are solid wood or good plywood, which take paint very well

Replace your cabinets if:

  • Doors are warped, cracked or will not stay aligned
  • There is water damage, swollen particleboard or crumbling boxes
  • The layout or storage truly does not work for your family
  • You are already doing a major kitchen renovation
  • You want premium features or custom sizes

The Cabinet Painting Process Step by Step

Prep and removal

Doors, drawers and hardware are removed and labeled so everything goes back where it belongs. Your floors, counters and appliances are protected, then every surface is cleaned and degreased.

Sanding and repairs

Surfaces are sanded for a good grip, and any holes, gouges or worn edges are filled and smoothed.

Bonding coat

A bonding coat of paint seals the surface and helps the color coats stick. This step matters most on glossy or previously stained cabinets.

Finish coats

Thin, even coats of cabinet-grade paint go on with proper drying time between them. A sprayed finish gives the smoothest result.

Reinstall and walkthrough

Doors are rehung and adjusted, hardware is reinstalled, and we do a final walkthrough with you. Our work comes with a 2-year written warranty.

Cabinet Painting FAQs

How long do painted cabinets last?

With good prep and quality paint, painted cabinets can look great for a long time. Areas around the sink and dishwasher take the most wear and may need touch-ups first. Wiping spills quickly and using your exhaust fan helps.

Can you paint over existing cabinet paint?

Yes, once the old finish is cleaned and sanded properly. If the old paint is peeling, more prep is needed first.

What color is best for kitchen cabinets?

White, soft gray, navy and sage green are all popular choices. The best one suits your countertops, floors and the light in your kitchen.

Can painted cabinets handle Savannah humidity?

Yes, when the right paint is used over proper prep. Coastal humidity is hard on poorly prepped cabinets, so this is where careful work counts. Running your exhaust fan while cooking helps too.

Is painting cheaper than staining?

They are often similar. Paint offers more color choices and hides grain differences, while stain keeps the look of natural wood. Choose by the look you want. Learn more about our cabinet painting service.

Get a Free Written Quote for Your Kitchen

Cabinet painting and replacement are both good choices in the right situation. If your cabinets are solid and you like the layout, painting gets you a dramatic change at a fraction of the cost and disruption. If the boxes are damaged or the layout does not work, replacement may be the better call.

We will look at your cabinets and tell you honestly which makes sense. Get a free estimate or call (912) 777-2650. Global Finishes serves Savannah, Pooler, Richmond Hill, Bluffton, Hilton Head and Beaufort. See our other painting services too.

More stories from our jobs

Every job gets its story.

Short films and write-ups from jobs we're proud of, what we found, what we did, what it looked like after. All stories

Where we work

Savannah is home. The Lowcountry is the route.

English and Spanish spoken on every crew · Licensed & insured · 2-year warranty

  • Savannah
  • Pooler
  • Richmond Hill
  • Rincon
  • Hinesville
  • Bluffton
  • Hilton Head
  • Beaufort
Based in Savannah, GA One crew and one number on both sides of the river, Georgia and South Carolina. Open in Google Maps →

Map tiles © Esri, HERE, Garmin, OpenStreetMap contributors

Ready when you are.

Free estimate. No pressure. The number we give you is the number you pay.

Call or text (912) 777-2650 or email estimates@globalfinishes.us

Or send it in writing. Carlos replies himself

We reply within one business day. Your info is never shared. By sending, you agree we may call or text you about your estimate.